Quiz · Hard
Eighteen MBE-style Evidence questions testing hearsay and its exceptions, impeachment, character evidence, privileges, the best evidence rule and the Confrontation Clause.
In a suit over a car accident, the plaintiff offers a witness's testimony that the defendant's mechanic said, the day after the accident, "I should have fixed those brakes last week." The mechanic is the defendant's employee and the statement concerns a matter within the scope of his job. Is the statement admissible against the defendant?
No, because it is hearsay not within any exception
Yes, as a statement of a party's employee within the scope of employment
No, because the mechanic is not a party
Yes, but only if the mechanic is unavailable
A statement by the opposing party's agent or employee on a matter within the scope of that relationship, made while it existed, is not hearsay under FRE 801(d)(2)(D). The speaker need not be a party, and no unavailability is required.
D is charged with robbery. The prosecution calls W, who testifies that D was the robber. D's lawyer wants to prove that W told a police officer last week that she "couldn't see the robber's face." The statement was not under oath. How may the prior statement be used?
To impeach W's credibility only, not for its truth
For its truth, as a prior inconsistent statement
For its truth, as a statement against interest
It is inadmissible for any purpose
A prior inconsistent statement not made under oath at a proceeding or deposition may be used to impeach but is not substantive evidence under FRE 801(d)(1)(A). The statement can be shown to the jury only to attack W's credibility.
In a negligence case arising from a collision, the plaintiff testifies that, as he was driving, a bystander shouted at the scene, "That truck ran the red light!" The bystander is unidentified. Is the testimony admissible to prove the truck ran the light?
No, because the declarant is unidentified and unavailable
No, because it is double hearsay
Yes, because statements of bystanders are not hearsay
Yes, as an excited utterance, if the bystander was under the stress of the startling event
An excited utterance relates to a startling event and is made under the stress of excitement caused by it (FRE 803(2)). The declarant need not be identified, though the court must find that the statement was made under stress. Availability of the declarant is irrelevant.
In a murder prosecution, the defendant offers evidence that the victim had a reputation for violence, to support a self-defense claim. Which statement is correct?
The evidence is inadmissible, because character evidence cannot be used to prove conduct
The evidence is admissible, but the prosecution may not rebut it
The evidence is admissible, and the prosecution may rebut with evidence of the defendant's same trait
The evidence is admissible only in the form of specific acts
Under FRE 404(a)(2)(B), a criminal defendant may offer evidence of a pertinent trait of the victim, and the prosecution may then offer evidence of the defendant's same trait. Reputation or opinion is the proper method (FRE 405(a)).
A witness for the plaintiff was convicted, eight years ago, of the misdemeanor of knowingly making a false statement on a loan application. The defendant seeks to impeach the witness with the conviction. Is it admissible?
No, because misdemeanors cannot be used for impeachment
Yes, because the crime involved a false statement, and such convictions are admissible for impeachment regardless of punishment
No, because the conviction is more than five years old
Yes, but only if the witness is the defendant
Under FRE 609(a)(2), any crime requiring proof of a dishonest act or false statement is admissible to impeach a witness's credibility, regardless of the punishment, if it is less than ten years old. Courts do not treat ordinary theft as crimen falsi.
In a suit for injuries from a slip on a stairway, the plaintiff offers evidence that, a week after the accident, the defendant installed a handrail. The defendant denies owning the stairway. For what purpose may the evidence be admitted?
To prove the defendant owned or controlled the stairway, if ownership is disputed
To prove the defendant's negligence
To prove the stairway was defective
It is not admissible for any purpose
Subsequent remedial measures are inadmissible to prove negligence or culpable conduct, but may be admitted for other purposes such as ownership or control, if disputed, feasibility of precautionary measures (if disputed), or impeachment (FRE 407).
A patient tells her doctor, "The stairs gave way when I stepped on them, and I hurt my back." The plaintiff offers this statement in her suit against the landlord. Which part is most clearly admissible under the exception for statements made for medical diagnosis or treatment?
"The stairs gave way when I stepped on them" as to fault
"The landlord knew the stairs were rotten"
None of the statements, since they were made to a doctor and not at the scene
"I hurt my back"
FRE 803(4) covers statements reasonably pertinent to diagnosis or treatment, including symptoms and the general cause of the injury. Statements assigning fault (the landlord knew) are not pertinent to treatment. The description of how the injury occurred is arguably admissible as general cause, but the symptom statement is the clearest.
The plaintiff in a contract case offers a letter from the defendant, mailed three years ago, to show that the defendant promised to pay 10,000 dollars. The plaintiff has only a photocopy because the original was lost in a fire. The defendant argues the best evidence rule. What is the likely ruling?
The copy is inadmissible, because the original is required
The copy is admissible only if the defendant admits the letter is genuine
The copy is admissible, because the original was lost without bad faith by the proponent
The copy is inadmissible, because it is hearsay
The best evidence rule (FRE 1002) requires the original to prove content, but FRE 1004 allows other evidence of the content if the original was lost or destroyed, unless the proponent lost or destroyed it in bad faith. The letter is not hearsay, because it is a party's own statement.
A defendant charged with arson calls an expert fire investigator, who testifies that, in his opinion, the fire was accidental. On cross-examination, the prosecutor asks whether the expert was paid by the defendant. Is the question proper?
No, because the expert's compensation is irrelevant
Yes, because it goes to bias
No, because it exceeds the scope of direct
No, because impeachment of experts is limited to prior convictions
Bias, interest, and compensation are always proper subjects of impeachment. The scope of cross includes matters affecting the witness's credibility, so the question is proper.
In a civil suit, Wife is called to testify about a conversation in which her husband told her he stole the goods at issue. Husband is a party. Which privilege may apply?
The confidential marital communications privilege, which can be asserted by either spouse
The spousal testimonial privilege, which only Wife holds
The attorney-client privilege
No privilege applies, because statements of a party are not hearsay
The confidential marital communications privilege protects confidential communications made during the marriage, and either spouse can assert it (in most jurisdictions). It is distinct from the spousal testimonial privilege, which allows the witness-spouse in some jurisdictions to refuse to testify against the other spouse, in criminal cases.
A defendant charged with embezzlement wants to testify and call a character witness to say he is an honest person. After the character witness testifies, the prosecutor asks him on cross, "Did you know that the defendant was fired from his last job for theft?" Is the question proper?
No, because specific acts may not be used to cross-examine a character witness
No, because the defendant did not testify
Yes, but only if the prosecutor proves the act by extrinsic evidence
Yes, to test the basis of the witness's opinion, if the prosecutor has a good faith basis
Under FRE 405(a), on cross-examination of a character witness, the court may allow inquiry into relevant specific instances of conduct, with a good faith basis. Extrinsic evidence is not allowed to prove the specific act, and the question must be limited to the trait at issue.
In a suit by an employee for wrongful termination, the employer offers a letter from the employee's former coworker, who is now dead, saying that the employee was caught stealing. Which is the best objection?
Relevance, because the statement is about a former job
Best evidence, because the letter is a copy
Hearsay, because no exception applies to a statement by a nonparty about someone else's misconduct
Lack of authentication, because the writer is dead
The letter is an out-of-court statement offered for its truth. The declarant is a non-party, so it is not an opposing party's statement, and a statement against interest requires that the statement be against the declarant's own interests. No exception applies. Authentication is possible by a witness familiar with the handwriting.
In a prosecution for drug distribution, the prosecution offers a statement by D's accomplice, made to the police after both were arrested, saying that D supplied the drugs. The accomplice refuses to testify. Which is the best objection?
Relevance
The Confrontation Clause, because the statement is testimonial and D has had no chance to cross-examine
Hearsay, but the statement is admissible as a co-conspirator's statement
The best evidence rule
A statement made to police in an investigation is testimonial. Under Crawford, it is inadmissible against D unless the declarant is unavailable and D had a prior opportunity to cross-examine. It is also not in furtherance of the conspiracy, because the conspiracy ended with the arrest.
A plaintiff offers a defendant's offer to pay her medical bills after an accident: "I'll cover your hospital bill, and I'm sorry I hit you." Which part, if any, is inadmissible to prove liability under the Federal Rules?
The offer to pay the bill, but the apology and statement of fault, as part of a statement of fact, may be admissible
Both statements, because they are offers of compromise
Neither statement, because both are party admissions
Only the apology, because it is a statement against interest
FRE 409 excludes offers to pay medical expenses, but not accompanying statements of fault, which can be admitted as admissions of a party. The offer to pay a bill is excluded to encourage humanitarian conduct. (Some states have apology statutes.) A settlement offer under FRE 408 involves a disputed claim, which these facts do not state.
In a civil case, the plaintiff testifies on direct that the light was green. On cross, the defense counsel asks her about her income tax return, which is outside of her direct testimony and unrelated to credibility. Under the federal rules, what is the proper ruling on a relevance and scope objection?
The court must overrule the objection, because cross is unlimited
The court must sustain the objection, with no discretion
The court must overrule the objection, because tax returns are always relevant
The court has discretion to allow it as if on direct, but may sustain the objection as beyond the scope of direct
Under FRE 611(b), cross-examination is limited to the subject matter of the direct and matters affecting credibility, but the court may allow inquiry into additional matters as if on direct. The ruling is within the judge's discretion. Many states allow wide-open cross.
A defendant charged with a crime wants to introduce a witness's testimony about what a now-deceased person said just before dying: "X shot me, not D." The defendant is on trial for assault of the deceased, not homicide, since the deceased died of another cause. Is the statement admissible as a dying declaration?
Yes, because the declarant believed death was imminent
Yes, because the declarant is unavailable
No, because it is not offered in a homicide prosecution or a civil case
No, because a dying declaration may be offered only by the prosecution
Under the federal rule, a dying declaration is admissible only in a homicide prosecution or a civil case (FRE 804(b)(2)). It cannot be used in other criminal prosecutions.
A police officer testifies that, upon arriving at the scene, a neighbor told him, "I saw a man in a red jacket run toward the park." The prosecution offers the statement to explain why the officer went to the park. Is the statement hearsay?
Yes, always, because it is an out-of-court statement
No, if offered only to explain the officer's actions, because it is not offered for its truth
Yes, because the neighbor is not a party
No, because it is a present sense impression
An out-of-court statement offered to show its effect on the listener, here to explain the officer's conduct, is not hearsay because it is not offered for its truth. A limiting instruction may be needed, and a court may exclude it under FRE 403 if the explanation is not needed.