Quiz · Hard
Bar-style fact patterns on irrevocable offers, the Statute of Frauds exceptions, mistake, parol evidence, battle of the forms, cure and cover, excuse doctrines, mitigation and specific performance.
On May 1, a seller writes, "I will sell you my car for $8,000. This offer is open until May 10." On May 5, the seller sells the car to someone else, and on May 6 the buyer hears about it from a friend. On May 8 the buyer tenders $8,000. Is there a contract?
Yes, because the offer stated it was open until May 10
Yes, because revocation must be communicated by the offeror
Yes, because the offeror received no consideration to hold the offer open
No, because the offer was revoked when the buyer learned of the sale from a reliable source (Dickinson v. Dodds)
An offer is revocable unless supported by an option, which needs consideration. Under Dickinson v. Dodds, indirect knowledge from a reliable source suffices for revocation.
A general contractor uses a subcontractor's $50,000 bid in its own bid. The subcontractor revokes before the general contractor accepts. The general contractor wins the project. Under the best view the general contractor can
not enforce it, because no acceptance occurred before revocation
enforce the bid, because it reasonably relied on it (Drennan v. Star Paving)
enforce it only if the subcontractor was a merchant
enforce it only for reliance damages measured by lost profits
Under Restatement §87(2), an offer that the offeror should reasonably expect to induce reliance is binding as an option contract to the extent necessary to avoid injustice.
Seller (a merchant) writes a signed note to Buyer, "Our offer to sell you 100 units at $5 stays open for 60 days." On day 30 Seller revokes, and Buyer accepts on day 40. Is Seller bound?
No, because offers cannot be irrevocable without consideration
No, because only offers to merchants are irrevocable
Yes, because under UCC 2-205 a signed merchant's firm offer is irrevocable for the stated period up to three months, without consideration
Yes, but only for a reasonable time of 10 days
A firm offer under UCC 2-205 requires a merchant, a signed writing, and an assurance it will be held open. It lasts for the stated time (not more than three months).
A sells Blackacre to B orally for $50,000. B pays $10,000, takes possession, and makes valuable improvements. A refuses to convey. A raises the Statute of Frauds. B will most likely
succeed, because part performance by possession and improvements takes the contract out of the Statute
lose, because land contracts must be in writing
lose, because part payment alone cannot avoid the Statute
succeed only if A's refusal was in bad faith
Part performance doctrine in land cases usually requires possession plus payment or improvements. Payment alone is usually insufficient.
Buyer orders custom-made furniture for $20,000 orally. Seller begins manufacturing but Buyer cancels. Seller sues. Buyer pleads the Statute of Frauds. Result?
Seller likely recovers, since the specially manufactured goods exception applies if goods are not suitable for sale to others and the seller has made substantial beginning
Buyer wins since $20,000 requires a writing
Buyer wins because the Statute requires a writing signed by the seller
Seller recovers only reliance damages
UCC 2-201(3)(a): specially manufactured goods exception. Seller must have made a substantial beginning before notice of repudiation.
A contracts to sell B a painting for $500, both believing it to be a copy. It is an original worth $50,000. A seeks to rescind. Which doctrine best supports A?
Unilateral mistake
Duress
Mutual mistake as to a basic assumption
Impossibility
Both parties were mistaken about the identity or nature of the subject matter, a basic assumption affecting the exchange. B would argue A bore the risk of the mistake (conscious ignorance).
A and B signed a one-page contract that states, "This writing is the entire agreement." A says B orally promised before signing to paint the fence too. This evidence is
admissible, because oral promises are always enforceable
barred by the parol evidence rule, because the writing is fully integrated
admissible, because it is a collateral agreement
admissible because B is a merchant
A merger clause is strong evidence of complete integration. The fence promise would be a prior agreement that adds a term, barred when the writing is fully integrated.
A supermarket chain contracts with a supplier for the supplier's "entire requirement" of milk for a year. Later the chain's needs grow to ten times its prior estimates because of a new business. Under UCC 2-306 the buyer
may demand any amount it wants
is limited to the stated estimate
may demand any amount if the contract does not mention estimates
may demand only a quantity that is not unreasonably disproportionate to the stated estimate or ordinary prior requirements
Quantity is measured by the buyer's good faith requirements, but a demand unreasonably disproportionate to estimates or prior requirements is not enforceable.
Under UCC 2-207, X offers to buy goods. Y's acknowledgment expressly states it is conditional on X's assent to Y's different terms. X does not assent but both parties perform. The terms of the contract are
Y's terms, since Y responded last
X's terms, since X made the offer
those on which the writings agree, plus UCC gap fillers
the terms of whichever party performed first
Under 2-207(3), conduct establishes a contract whose terms are those on which the writings of the parties agree, supplemented by the UCC.
A buyer agrees to purchase 1,000 widgets. The seller delivers 1,000 widgets with minor cosmetic scratches. The buyer wants to reject. The seller promptly notifies it will deliver replacements within the delivery period. The buyer
must permit the cure, because the time for performance has not expired
may reject without allowing a cure
must accept the scratched goods
may reject only if the goods are unmerchantable
UCC 2-508(1) allows the seller to cure a nonconforming tender before the contract time expires by timely notice and conforming delivery.
A manufacturer repudiates a contract to supply a retailer on March 1, with delivery due June 1. The retailer immediately buys substitute goods at a higher price on March 15 and sues. The measure of damages is
only the market price on June 1
the retailer's lost profits only
nothing, because performance was not yet due
the cover price minus the contract price, plus incidental and consequential damages, less expenses saved
Anticipatory repudiation lets the buyer cover (2-712) without waiting. The buyer might alternatively recover market-minus-contract damages (2-713).
A violinist is hired for a concert and the concert hall burns down the day before. The contract is
breached by the violinist
discharged because performance became impossible without fault
enforceable by damages against the hall owner only
enforceable, with the violinist paid anyway
Taylor v. Caldwell: destruction of the specific subject matter discharges both parties' duties. Restitution for any benefits already conferred may be allowed.
D rents a room for a day to watch a royal parade. The parade is canceled. The best argument that D need not pay is
impossibility of performance
frustration of purpose
mutual mistake
unconscionability
Krell v. Henry: performance was still possible, but the principal purpose of the contract for both parties was destroyed by a supervening event.
A and B contract for A's construction of B's house, and A uses a different brand of pipe than specified. The pipes are identical in quality. B refuses to pay and sues for the cost of replacing the pipes. Under Jacob & Youngs v. Kent
B can recover the full replacement cost
B need not pay anything
B can rescind the contract
B can recover only the difference in value, if any, since A substantially performed
The deviation was trivial and unintentional, so substantial performance applies. Replacement would be economic waste.
A signs a contract to sell her business to B, a competitor, for $1M. B repudiates. A can prove lost profits only as the difference between the price and the value of the business, which is speculative. A could instead recover
reliance damages
punitive damages
specific performance of the full price
nominal damages only
When expectation damages are too uncertain, a plaintiff may elect reliance damages, putting her back where she stood before the contract.
A wrongfully discharged chef is offered a job at a lower-paying restaurant of lesser rank in a distant city. Under the mitigation rule the chef
must accept it or lose all damages
must accept it and sue for the difference
need not accept it, because it is not comparable employment
must accept any job
The duty to mitigate requires only reasonable efforts to find comparable work (Parker v. Twentieth Century-Fox).
A contract fixes damages of $50,000 for each day of delay in completing a stadium; actual harm from a day of delay is about $48,000 and was hard to measure beforehand. The clause is
an unenforceable penalty because it is larger than the harm
unenforceable because damages are measurable
enforceable only if the contractor agrees
enforceable as liquidated damages
A reasonable forecast of actual loss, given difficulty of estimating, is enforceable. A clause grossly disproportionate to anticipated loss would be a penalty.
Assignor A has a contract with Obligor O. A assigns his right to payment to C. A's contract has a clause saying "no assignment of rights allowed." C sues O. Under the modern majority view
the assignment is always void
the assignment is effective unless the clause clearly states the assignment is void, though A may be liable for breach
C wins regardless of the clause
the clause is ineffective in all cases
Anti-assignment clauses are narrowly construed. UCC 9-406 and 2-210 override clauses in certain contexts.
In a sale of goods, the buyer takes delivery and uses the goods for two weeks before discovering a defect that substantially impairs their value, which was difficult to discover. The buyer may
not revoke because it already accepted
only recover damages
revoke acceptance within a reasonable time after discovery and before any substantial change in condition
only reject, not revoke
UCC 2-608 allows revocation of acceptance for a nonconformity that substantially impairs value if the buyer accepted without discovery, and discovery was difficult.
A unique painting is promised to a buyer for $10,000, and the seller refuses to deliver. The buyer seeks specific performance. The court is likely to
grant it, because the painting is unique and damages are inadequate
deny it, because courts never order sales
deny it, because the buyer has an adequate remedy in damages
grant it only if the seller agrees
Specific performance is available when damages are inadequate, as with unique goods or land.
A and B's contract is silent on warranties. A sells B a used lawnmower, and A is not a merchant of lawnmowers. The mower proves defective. Which warranty is least likely to apply?
Implied warranty of merchantability
Express warranty from A's statements
Implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose, if the seller knew B's particular purpose
Warranty of title
The implied warranty of merchantability applies only to merchants who deal in goods of that kind. A casual seller is not a merchant.