StudyFox
कीमतेंब्लॉगएक्सटेंशनमुफ़्त टूल
  • कीमतें
  • ब्लॉग
  • एक्सटेंशन
  • मुफ़्त टूल
  • शुरू करेंसाइन इन
StudyFox

अपने नोट्स, PDF और स्लाइड्स को फ़्लैशकार्ड, क्विज़, नोट्स और माइंड मैप में बदलें।

StudyFox खोलें

स्टडी टूल्स

  • होमवर्क हेल्पर
  • नोट मेकर
  • फ़्लैशकार्ड मेकर
  • क्विज़ मेकर
  • माइंड मैप मेकर

प्रोडक्ट

  • कीमतें
  • Chrome एक्सटेंशन
  • मुफ़्त एक्सटेंशन
  • स्टडी सेट देखें
  • ब्लॉग

सहायता

  • सहायता केंद्र
  • संपर्क करें
  • गोपनीयता नीति
  • सेवा की शर्तें

तुलना करें

  • Chegg का विकल्प
  • Course Hero का विकल्प
  • Coursology का विकल्प
  • Photomath का विकल्प
  • Gauthmath का विकल्प
  • PhotoSolve का विकल्प
  • CollegeTools का विकल्प
  • Transcript का विकल्प
  • SmartSolve का विकल्प
  • Homeworkify का विकल्प
  • AnswersAi का विकल्प
  • StudyX का विकल्प
  • Quizlet का विकल्प
  • Anki का विकल्प
  • Knowt का विकल्प
  • Brainscape का विकल्प
  • सभी तुलनाएँ

© 2026 StudyFox AI. सर्वाधिकार सुरक्षित।

  • X
  • Discord
  • Instagram
ExploreSocial StudiesPhilosophyPolitical Philosophy: Rawls, Nozick, Liberty and Legitimacy (Advanced)

Quiz · Hard

Political Philosophy: Rawls, Nozick, Liberty and Legitimacy (Advanced)

Harder questions on the debates around Rawls and Nozick, communitarianism, republican freedom, hypothetical consent and political obligation.

by Kill h.15 questionsCreated Nov 20, 2026, 08:28 PM
Philosophy· Political PhilosophyTags#political-philosophy#justice#rawls#nozick#advanced

15 questions

  1. 1

    Rawls claims that the parties in the original position would reject utilitarianism mainly because...

    • it might sacrifice the basic liberties of some for aggregate welfare

    • B

      it ignores consequences

    • C

      it requires the veil of ignorance

    • D

      it supports equal liberty too strongly

    Under uncertainty about their position, rational parties would not risk becoming a sacrificed minority. They would pick principles securing basic liberties.

  2. 2

    A critic says Rawls's parties are 'unencumbered selves' stripped of identity. This is the line of...

    • A

      Libertarians such as Nozick

    • B

      Hobbesian contractarians

    • C

      Classical utilitarians

    • Communitarians such as Sandel

    Sandel's Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1982) argues that persons are constituted by their ends and attachments. Nozick criticizes Rawls on rights and redistribution.

  3. 3

    In Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain example, the main point is that...

    • A

      fans should not pay to watch sports

    • any patterned distribution is upset by voluntary transfers

    • C

      talent deserves payment

    • D

      inequality is always unjust

    If people freely transfer part of their just holdings, an unequal distribution results without injustice. Thus patterned principles require continuous interference with liberty.

  4. 4

    Which is NOT part of Rawls's second principle of justice?

    • A

      Fair equality of opportunity

    • Equal share of resources for all

    • C

      The difference principle

    • D

      Inequalities attached to open positions

    The second principle allows inequalities if they benefit the least advantaged and attach to open positions; it does not require strict equal shares.

  5. 5

    Berlin worried that positive liberty can be abused because...

    • A

      it denies any role for the state

    • B

      it ignores equality

    • C

      it makes freedom purely negative

    • it can justify forcing people to be 'free' by their true rational self

    If a ruler claims to know my 'real' self, coercion can be described as liberation. Rousseau's 'forced to be free' is the standard target.

  6. 6

    Pettit's republican freedom differs from negative liberty because...

    • a person can be unfree if subject to someone's arbitrary power, even without actual interference

    • B

      it requires democratic participation by all

    • C

      it denies all constraints

    • D

      it values equality over liberty

    A slave with a kind master is dominated though unimpeded. Pettit calls freedom 'non-domination'.

  7. 7

    The strongest objection to a hypothetical-consent defence of the state is that...

    • A

      people never disagree

    • B

      it requires unanimity

    • hypothetical consent is not actual consent, so it may not bind anyone

    • D

      it assumes the state of nature was peaceful

    Dworkin objected that a hypothetical contract is not simply a pale form of an actual contract; it is no contract at all. Defenders say its force lies in the reasons it models, not in consent.

  8. 8

    Which pair of thinkers disagrees most sharply about the justification of redistribution?

    • A

      Locke and Rousseau

    • B

      Hobbes and Machiavelli

    • C

      Marx and Engels

    • Rawls and Nozick

    Rawls's difference principle permits and requires redistribution; Nozick treats it as a rights violation beyond the minimal state.

  9. 9

    The 'Lockean proviso' states that appropriation is legitimate only if...

    • enough and as good is left for others

    • B

      the owner has the king's permission

    • C

      it is farmed for at least ten years

    • D

      the owner is a citizen

    Locke's proviso constrains labour-based acquisition. Nozick revised it as a 'no worsening' requirement.

  10. 10

    Which view holds that no state has a legitimate claim to obedience as such?

    • A

      Contractarianism

    • B

      Republicanism

    • Philosophical anarchism

    • D

      Conservatism

    Philosophical anarchists (Wolff, Simmons) deny a general political obligation. Contractarians justify the state by (hypothetical) agreement.

  11. 11

    Hayek's critique of central planning rests on...

    • A

      the immorality of equality

    • the dispersed, local knowledge that planners cannot gather

    • C

      the claim that markets are perfectly fair

    • D

      the labour theory of value

    The knowledge problem is epistemic: prices aggregate information no single planner has.

  12. 12

    Arendt's 'banality of evil' suggests that...

    • great evil can be carried out by unreflective, ordinary functionaries

    • B

      evil is always the work of monsters

    • C

      totalitarianism is natural

    • D

      evil does not exist

    Her report on Eichmann stressed thoughtlessness, not demonic motives. It is a claim about his character, not an excuse.

  13. 13

    In Hobbes's theory, what limits the sovereign's authority?

    • A

      The sovereign must consult parliament

    • B

      A separation of powers

    • Subjects keep the right of self-preservation, and obligation ends if the sovereign cannot protect them

    • D

      Natural rights to property

    Hobbes's sovereign is absolute in law, but the contract's purpose is security, so there is no duty to harm oneself. Separation of powers is Montesquieu; rights to property are Lockean.

  14. 14

    Which statement correctly contrasts Marx with Rawls?

    • A

      Marx favours the original position; Rawls favours historical materialism

    • Marx explains political institutions by the economic base; Rawls evaluates institutions by principles chosen in an original position

    • C

      Both claim justice is timeless and separate from economics

    • D

      Rawls rejects equal liberty; Marx defends it

    Marx's historical materialism is explanatory and critical, whereas Rawls develops a normative theory of justice for the basic structure.

  15. 15

    The idea that justice should be assessed by what people can actually do and be is called...

    • A

      the difference principle

    • B

      maximin

    • C

      luck egalitarianism

    • the capabilities approach

    Sen and Nussbaum argue that resources alone miss differences in people's ability to convert them into functionings.