Quiz · Hard
Applied questions on mixtures, statistics, contamination, database searching and the limits of forensic biology evidence.
At a locus, a mixture sample shows 7 alleles. What is the minimum number of contributors?
7
2
3
4
Each person has at most 2 alleles at a locus. 7 alleles need at least 4 people since 3 people give at most 6.
An evidence profile has alleles 12, 14, 15 at D8S1179 with 12 and 14 tall and 15 short. The suspect is 12, 14. Which is the most defensible interpretation?
The suspect is not excluded; the 15 may be from a minor contributor, stutter excluded by size
The suspect is excluded because of the 15
The sample must be from three people
The 15 must be stutter
A suspect who has all the major alleles is not excluded. The 15 is not one repeat smaller than a 12 or 14, so it is not stutter (stutter of 16 would give 15). The minor contributor explains the 15.
A forensic lab reports a profile frequency of 1 in 10 billion. A prosecutor says 'there is only a 1 in 10 billion chance the defendant is innocent'. What error is this?
Base-rate neglect only
Prosecutor's fallacy
Stutter
Defense fallacy
The RMP is the chance that a random person matches, not the probability of innocence given the match. The posterior probability depends on all the other evidence.
Heterozygote with peak heights 900 and 150 RFU at the same locus at a locus in an otherwise single-source profile with no third allele. What is a likely explanation?
Normal heterozygote balance
Allele ladder error
Strong imbalance from low-template effects or a degraded sample
A tri-allelic pattern
Heterozygote peaks are normally within about a 60 percent ratio. A 1:6 ratio signals stochastic effects, degradation or a mixture.
Alleles are 14 and 15 on a mother, 15 and 16 on a father, and the child is 14, 16. Which is the correct statement for the child's 16?
It cannot be determined
It is from the mother
It is from the father
It is a mutation
The mother has no 16, so the 16 must come from the father. The 14 comes from the mother. The child's 14,16 is consistent.
In a trial, an analyst says the likelihood ratio is 1,000,000. What does this mean?
The suspect has a million relatives
There is a 1 in a million chance of match
The evidence is a million times more likely if the suspect is the contributor than if an unrelated person is
The suspect is a million times more likely to be guilty
The LR compares probabilities of the evidence under two propositions. It is not the probability of guilt.
Why might a DNA match between a suspect and the weapon not prove the suspect used it?
The weapon was not tested for fingerprints
The match was by mtDNA
DNA is not unique
DNA can be transferred indirectly, so the result says nothing about how or when it got there
Source level and activity level are different questions. Touch DNA can transfer.
Which pair is the best use of the two methods?
Amelogenin for individual identification
STR for a rootless hair, mtDNA for fresh blood
Y-STR for a female victim's DNA
mtDNA for a rootless hair, STRs for a blood stain
mtDNA suits samples without nuclear DNA. STRs give higher discrimination where nuclear DNA is present.
A sexual assault swab shows a profile of female alleles only after standard extraction, but sperm are seen on the slide. What is the best next step?
Differential extraction, or Y-STR typing
Report no male DNA
Repeat the same extraction at the same conditions
Use luminol
The female DNA swamps the sperm DNA, so separating sperm cells or targeting male DNA with Y-STRs is the usual solution.
An electropherogram has a small peak exactly one repeat smaller than a tall allele peak, at 8 percent of its height. What is it most probably?
Pull-up
A second contributor
Allele drop-in
Stutter
Stutter is typically below about 15 percent of the parent peak and one repeat smaller. Pull-up lines up with a peak in another color.
Which is the reason that the product rule can be used for CODIS loci?
Each locus has only two alleles
Y-STRs are included
The loci have equal allele frequencies
The loci are on different chromosomes or far apart, so they are inherited independently
Independence (no linkage) lets frequencies be multiplied.
A cold case sample gives a partial profile that has a partial match to an offender in a database search, matching one allele at each of many loci. This suggests:
The profile is a mixture
The offender is the source
The data are wrong
A close relative may be the source
Parent, child or sibling share about half their alleles. This is how familial searches work.
A cleaned floor glows weakly with luminol, but a Kastle-Meyer test on a swab of the spot is negative. What is the best conclusion?
Bleach is not involved
The stain is from an animal
Blood is not confirmed; the glow may come from another substance or too little blood
Blood is confirmed
Luminol is a very sensitive but non-specific screen, so a glow with a negative follow-up test leaves blood unconfirmed. Further testing or DNA is needed.
Which fact gives hair evidence limited value when only microscopy is used?
Hair never transfers
Hair has no cortex
Different people can have hairs with similar features
Hair does not contain DNA at all
Class-level features are shared, so microscopy cannot individualize.
Calculate: p = 0.2 for allele 12 at a locus where the person is homozygous 12,12. Genotype frequency by Hardy-Weinberg?
0.08
0.04
0.2
0.4
Homozygote frequency is . A heterozygote would use .
Why does a contaminated negative control invalidate a batch?
The samples run with it could also have been contaminated
Negative controls always have peaks
The controls are not used in interpretation
It shows the sex
Contamination in the blank shows a process failure, so associated results cannot be trusted until investigated.