Quiz · Hard
Bar-style fact patterns on felony murder, Pinkerton liability, legal impossibility, battered spouse self-defense, suppression after illegal arrests, Strickland, Apprendi and juvenile and capital sentencing.
D hands a loaded gun to V, an acquaintance with a violent history, and says, "Shoot X." V shoots and kills X. D's best-supported liability is
no liability because D did not fire the gun
conspiracy only, because V acted alone
involuntary manslaughter, because D did not intend X's death
accomplice liability for murder, with D also guilty of solicitation (merging into the completed offense)
D aided and encouraged with intent that X be killed, so he is an accomplice to murder. Solicitation merges into the completed offense. Conspiracy would also be possible, but the target offense can be charged as well.
A and B conspire to burglarize a house. During the burglary, B shoots and kills an occupant. A was waiting outside. Under Pinkerton, A is
not liable, because he did not kill
liable for the murder, if the killing was reasonably foreseeable and in furtherance of the conspiracy
liable only for conspiracy
liable only if he knew B was armed
Pinkerton imposes liability on a conspirator for foreseeable crimes committed by co-conspirators in furtherance. Some states (and the MPC) reject Pinkerton.
D, intending to steal, pushes a victim to take a wallet, and the victim falls and dies from the head injury. Which charge is most likely?
Voluntary manslaughter
Larceny only
Felony murder, based on robbery
Involuntary manslaughter only, as there was no intent to kill
Robbery is an inherently dangerous enumerated felony. A death caused during it is felony murder even without intent to kill.
D intends to commit larceny by taking a coat from a coat rack, but the coat is his own. Prosecutors charge attempted larceny. Which is the best defense?
Legal impossibility: even if the plan succeeded, taking one's own property is not larceny
Factual impossibility
Abandonment
Entrapment
If the act completed as D believed would not be a crime, it is true legal impossibility. Factual impossibility (empty pocket) is no defense.
D takes an umbrella from a restaurant rack, honestly but unreasonably believing it is his own. D is charged with larceny. D's mistake of fact
is a defense, because it negates the intent to permanently deprive another of property
is no defense, because the belief was unreasonable
is a defense only if the belief was reasonable
is irrelevant, because larceny is a strict liability offense
Larceny is a specific intent crime, so even an unreasonable honest mistake negates the required intent. For general intent crimes the mistake would have to be reasonable.
Which would most strongly support a charge of depraved heart murder rather than involuntary manslaughter?
The defendant drove 5 mph over the speed limit and hit a pedestrian
The defendant forgot to lock a door
The defendant fired a rifle through a crowded room for amusement
The defendant played with an unloaded gun
Depraved heart (extreme recklessness) requires a very high risk and indifference to human life. Mere negligence or minor recklessness is involuntary manslaughter.
D is charged with a crime requiring proof of a mental state. The prosecution offers evidence that D must have known the result was practically certain. This evidence is relevant to which MPC culpability level?
Purposely
Knowingly
Recklessly
Negligently
Knowingly is awareness that the result is practically certain. Purposely requires a conscious object to cause it.
A statute criminalizes possession of a controlled substance and is silent on mens rea. Under Morissette, courts will most likely
treat the crime as strict liability because the statute is silent
refuse to enforce the statute
require proof of purpose to distribute
read in a requirement that the defendant knew of the possession
Courts presume that Congress did not dispense with mens rea. Silence in the statute leads to an implied knowledge requirement, unless it is a public welfare offense.
D, a battered spouse, kills her sleeping abuser. Which claim is hardest to establish?
Heat of passion manslaughter
Insanity
Self-defense, because the threat was not imminent
Imperfect self-defense in a minority of states
Self-defense requires an imminent threat. Most courts do not find imminence while the abuser is asleep, though some allow evidence of battered spouse syndrome to show reasonableness.
The police stop a car for a broken taillight, order the driver out, arrest him for driving without a license, and search the passenger compartment after securing him in the patrol car. Under Arizona v. Gant, the search is
unlawful unless police reasonably believed evidence of the offense of arrest was in the car
lawful as a search incident to arrest
lawful under the plain view doctrine
lawful as an inventory search without any other showing
After the arrestee is secured and cannot reach the car, Gant allows a search incident to arrest only if it is reasonable to believe evidence of the offense of arrest is inside. Evidence of a license violation would not be.
After an illegal arrest, the defendant is given Miranda warnings and confesses at the station. The confession is most likely
admissible, because Miranda warnings cured the problem
admissible, because confessions are never excluded
suppressed only if no warnings were given
suppressed as a fruit of the illegal arrest, unless attenuation applies
Miranda warnings alone do not break the causal chain from an illegal arrest (Brown v. Illinois). Courts look at the time elapsed, intervening circumstances, and the flagrancy of the misconduct.
A defense lawyer fails to investigate an alibi witness and the defendant is convicted. To win an ineffective assistance claim, the defendant must show
only deficient performance
deficient performance and a reasonable probability of a different outcome
that the lawyer was not licensed
that the verdict was wrong
Strickland has two prongs: deficient performance and prejudice.
A prosecutor strikes all Black jurors with peremptory challenges without explanation. Which case governs?
Crawford v. Washington
Batson v. Kentucky
Strickland v. Washington
Apprendi v. New Jersey
Batson sets a three-step procedure for race-based peremptory challenges: prima facie case, race-neutral explanation, then the court's determination.
A judge sentences a defendant above the statutory maximum based on facts found by the judge by a preponderance of the evidence. Under Apprendi, the sentence is
constitutional, because judges decide sentences
constitutional if the facts are in a presentence report
unconstitutional only for capital cases
unconstitutional, because the facts must be found by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt
Any fact (except a prior conviction) that increases the maximum penalty must be found by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt.
A state sentences a 16-year-old to mandatory life without parole for a homicide. Which case most directly makes this unconstitutional?
Miller v. Alabama
Roper v. Simmons
Atkins v. Virginia
Coker v. Georgia
Miller held that mandatory life without parole for juveniles violates the Eighth Amendment. Roper concerned the death penalty for offenders under 18.
D, a getaway driver, did not kill and did not intend that anyone be killed. He was only a minor participant. Can the state impose a death sentence for the felony murder?
Yes, because felony murder imposes full liability
Yes, if the jury recommends it
No, under Enmund, because he did not kill or intend to kill and was not a major participant with reckless indifference
Yes, because death is proportionate to murder
Enmund barred death for a non-killer who lacked intent. Tison allows it for a major participant who acted with reckless indifference to human life.
True or false: A state and the federal government may both prosecute a defendant for the same conduct without violating the Double Jeopardy Clause.
True
False
Under the dual sovereignty doctrine, reaffirmed in Gamble v. United States (2019), separate sovereigns may each prosecute.
Which of the following facts would NOT support an entrapment defense under the federal subjective test?
The defendant had no criminal history and refused several times before being pressured
The defendant had previously sold drugs and readily accepted an undercover officer's offer
The officer repeatedly pleaded and appealed to the defendant's sympathy
The government supplied all the means for the crime to an unwilling target
A predisposed defendant is not entrapped, even if the government provided the opportunity. Entrapment requires inducement plus lack of predisposition.
A defendant is charged with murder. The state requires the defendant to prove he acted in the heat of passion by a preponderance in order to reduce the charge, and malice is presumed otherwise. Under Mullaney v. Wilbur this scheme is
constitutional, because states may define defenses
constitutional because Patterson allows it
unconstitutional, because it shifts the burden on an element (absence of heat of passion) of the offense as defined
unconstitutional only in capital cases
Mullaney forbids shifting to the defendant the burden of disproving an element, here malice. Patterson permits placing the burden of an affirmative defense that does not negate an element.