Quiz · Hard
Harder questions on the debates around Rawls and Nozick, communitarianism, republican freedom, hypothetical consent and political obligation.
Rawls claims that the parties in the original position would reject utilitarianism mainly because...
it might sacrifice the basic liberties of some for aggregate welfare
it ignores consequences
it requires the veil of ignorance
it supports equal liberty too strongly
Under uncertainty about their position, rational parties would not risk becoming a sacrificed minority. They would pick principles securing basic liberties.
A critic says Rawls's parties are 'unencumbered selves' stripped of identity. This is the line of...
Libertarians such as Nozick
Hobbesian contractarians
Classical utilitarians
Communitarians such as Sandel
Sandel's Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (1982) argues that persons are constituted by their ends and attachments. Nozick criticizes Rawls on rights and redistribution.
In Nozick's Wilt Chamberlain example, the main point is that...
fans should not pay to watch sports
any patterned distribution is upset by voluntary transfers
talent deserves payment
inequality is always unjust
If people freely transfer part of their just holdings, an unequal distribution results without injustice. Thus patterned principles require continuous interference with liberty.
Which is NOT part of Rawls's second principle of justice?
Fair equality of opportunity
Equal share of resources for all
The difference principle
Inequalities attached to open positions
The second principle allows inequalities if they benefit the least advantaged and attach to open positions; it does not require strict equal shares.
Berlin worried that positive liberty can be abused because...
it denies any role for the state
it ignores equality
it makes freedom purely negative
it can justify forcing people to be 'free' by their true rational self
If a ruler claims to know my 'real' self, coercion can be described as liberation. Rousseau's 'forced to be free' is the standard target.
Pettit's republican freedom differs from negative liberty because...
a person can be unfree if subject to someone's arbitrary power, even without actual interference
it requires democratic participation by all
it denies all constraints
it values equality over liberty
A slave with a kind master is dominated though unimpeded. Pettit calls freedom 'non-domination'.
The strongest objection to a hypothetical-consent defence of the state is that...
people never disagree
it requires unanimity
hypothetical consent is not actual consent, so it may not bind anyone
it assumes the state of nature was peaceful
Dworkin objected that a hypothetical contract is not simply a pale form of an actual contract; it is no contract at all. Defenders say its force lies in the reasons it models, not in consent.
Which pair of thinkers disagrees most sharply about the justification of redistribution?
Locke and Rousseau
Hobbes and Machiavelli
Marx and Engels
Rawls and Nozick
Rawls's difference principle permits and requires redistribution; Nozick treats it as a rights violation beyond the minimal state.
The 'Lockean proviso' states that appropriation is legitimate only if...
enough and as good is left for others
the owner has the king's permission
it is farmed for at least ten years
the owner is a citizen
Locke's proviso constrains labour-based acquisition. Nozick revised it as a 'no worsening' requirement.
Which view holds that no state has a legitimate claim to obedience as such?
Contractarianism
Republicanism
Philosophical anarchism
Conservatism
Philosophical anarchists (Wolff, Simmons) deny a general political obligation. Contractarians justify the state by (hypothetical) agreement.
Hayek's critique of central planning rests on...
the immorality of equality
the dispersed, local knowledge that planners cannot gather
the claim that markets are perfectly fair
the labour theory of value
The knowledge problem is epistemic: prices aggregate information no single planner has.
Arendt's 'banality of evil' suggests that...
great evil can be carried out by unreflective, ordinary functionaries
evil is always the work of monsters
totalitarianism is natural
evil does not exist
Her report on Eichmann stressed thoughtlessness, not demonic motives. It is a claim about his character, not an excuse.
In Hobbes's theory, what limits the sovereign's authority?
The sovereign must consult parliament
A separation of powers
Subjects keep the right of self-preservation, and obligation ends if the sovereign cannot protect them
Natural rights to property
Hobbes's sovereign is absolute in law, but the contract's purpose is security, so there is no duty to harm oneself. Separation of powers is Montesquieu; rights to property are Lockean.
Which statement correctly contrasts Marx with Rawls?
Marx favours the original position; Rawls favours historical materialism
Marx explains political institutions by the economic base; Rawls evaluates institutions by principles chosen in an original position
Both claim justice is timeless and separate from economics
Rawls rejects equal liberty; Marx defends it
Marx's historical materialism is explanatory and critical, whereas Rawls develops a normative theory of justice for the basic structure.
The idea that justice should be assessed by what people can actually do and be is called...
the difference principle
maximin
luck egalitarianism
the capabilities approach
Sen and Nussbaum argue that resources alone miss differences in people's ability to convert them into functionings.