Quiz · Hard
Applied scenarios on anonymous sources, actual malice, false balance, FOIA and broadcast style.
A source tells you a damaging fact about a city official only if you promise never to name them. You cannot confirm it elsewhere. The most defensible choice is to:
Keep looking for independent confirmation; do not publish the claim unverified
Publish it attributed to 'sources say' since you promised anonymity
Name the source to protect the newsroom
Publish it as a rumor in a sidebar
Anonymity does not replace verification. Naming the source breaks the promise; labeling it rumor still publishes an unverified defamatory claim.
The Pentagon Papers decision (1971) is important because it:
Created the actual malice rule
Established FOIA
Held that reporters need not testify before grand juries
Refused to allow prior restraint against newspapers publishing classified material
Sullivan created actual malice; FOIA is a statute; the reporter's privilege was addressed in Branzburg (1972), which went against reporters.
A mayor sues a paper over a story containing a false statement made by mistake after normal checking. Under Sullivan, the mayor will most likely:
Win because the statement was false
Win because he is a public official
Lose unless he proves the paper knew it was false or recklessly disregarded the truth
Lose only if the paper printed a correction first
Falsity alone is not enough for a public official: actual malice must be proven. A correction can reduce damages but is not the test.
Which scenario best fits 'false balance'?
A report quotes both sides of a close local election
A report includes the mayor's response to criticism
A report corrects a previous error
A report gives equal time to a fringe denial of a well-established scientific finding
False balance misrepresents the weight of evidence. Quoting both candidates or giving a subject right of reply is normal fairness.
A press release arrives with an embargo until 9 a.m. Tuesday. A reporter breaks it at 8 a.m. What is the most serious consequence?
A prior restraint injunction
Damaged trust: the source may stop providing early access and the outlet may be barred
Criminal libel charges
Automatic loss of copyright
Embargoes are agreements, not laws. Breaking one usually carries professional consequences, not legal ones.
Which of these is a conflict of interest that should be disclosed or avoided?
A business reporter writing about a company in which she owns shares
A sports reporter covering a team's loss
A reporter attending a public hearing
An editor reading a draft
Financial stakes in the subject can compromise independence or its appearance. The other options are ordinary work.
A newsroom publishes an advertiser-paid article styled like a news story with no label. The main problem is:
It breaks the inverted pyramid format
It is automatically libelous
It violates FOIA
Readers are misled about who is behind the content
Sponsored content must be clearly labeled. Format and FOIA are irrelevant to the ethical issue.
A federal agency denies a FOIA request citing the privacy of named individuals. Which statement is accurate?
FOIA has exemptions, including for personal privacy, so a denial can be lawful, but requesters can appeal
FOIA has no exemptions
FOIA only applies to state governments
The agency must always provide full unredacted records
FOIA covers federal agencies and has nine exemptions (privacy, national security, etc.). Partial redaction is common.
In a broadcast script, which version follows good radio and TV style?
'The driver, police say, was drunk.'
'Allegedly drunk, the driver was arrested, according to police sources.'
'Police say the driver was drunk.'
'Drunk driving by the driver was alleged by police.'
Attribution first, short active sentence, present tense. The others bury the attribution, are wordy, or are passive.
Which headline is best for a hard news story?
Council Does Something Amazing for Readers
Library funding: what this means
City council approves $2 million for new library
You won't believe what the council just did
The first is specific, active and informative. The others are vague or clickbait.
A reporter notices a quote from a mayor in a rival paper's story and uses it in her own story without checking, writing as if she heard it. This is best described as:
Fair comment
A plagiarism and verification failure
Acceptable aggregation
On-background reporting
Quotes must be obtained or credited ('told the Courier'). Passing others' reporting off as your own is plagiarism.
Which is the strongest example of an investigative story's evidence?
A single anonymous post
Original documents and records obtained and verified with multiple sources
A press release from the subject
A summary on social media
Investigations rest on documents, data and independent corroboration, not single unverified claims.
A shield law gives journalists complete protection from ever testifying in any court.
True
False
Shield laws vary and most are qualified; courts can compel disclosure in some circumstances. There is no federal shield law.
A photographer removes a distracting object from a news photo using editing software. The ethical standard says this is:
Acceptable if no one notices
Not acceptable in news photography, which should not be altered beyond basic adjustments
Acceptable if the caption mentions it
Required for beauty
News images must represent reality; basic toning and cropping are allowed, but adding or removing content is not.
Which describes solutions journalism?
Rigorous reporting on how people respond to problems and what evidence shows about results
Cheerful news without criticism
Opinion pieces proposing laws
Press releases from nonprofits
Solutions journalism still scrutinizes outcomes; it is not advocacy or uncritical positivity.