Quiz · Medium
Sixteen MBE-style questions on diversity and federal question jurisdiction, personal jurisdiction, Rule 12, joinder, discovery, trial motions, preclusion and appeals.
P, a citizen of Ohio, sues D, a citizen of Texas, in federal court in Ohio for 60,000 dollars. P adds a second claim against D for 20,000 dollars on an unrelated matter. Does the court have diversity jurisdiction?
No, because each claim is below 75,000 dollars
Yes, because P can aggregate all claims against D, giving 80,000 dollars
No, because the claims are unrelated
No, because P is suing in his home state
A single plaintiff may aggregate all claims, related or not, against a single defendant to satisfy the amount in controversy. Diversity is complete (Ohio v. Texas) and the aggregate exceeds 75,000 dollars. Suing in the plaintiff's home state does not matter.
P, a citizen of California, sues D1, a citizen of California, and D2, a citizen of New York, in federal court in California, for 100,000 dollars on a state-law negligence claim. What is the result?
The court lacks diversity jurisdiction, because P and D1 are both citizens of California
The court has jurisdiction because D2 is diverse
The court has jurisdiction if D1 consents
The court has supplemental jurisdiction over D1
Diversity must be complete: no plaintiff may share citizenship with any defendant (Strawbridge v. Curtiss). Supplemental jurisdiction cannot be used to add a nondiverse defendant to destroy diversity.
A corporation is incorporated in Delaware, and its headquarters, where its officers direct its activities, are in Georgia. A plaintiff from Georgia sues it in federal court on a state-law claim for 200,000 dollars. Is there diversity?
Yes, because the corporation is a citizen of Delaware
Yes, because the amount exceeds 75,000 dollars
No, because corporations cannot be diverse
No, because the corporation is also a citizen of Georgia
A corporation is a citizen of both its state of incorporation and the state of its principal place of business, its nerve center (Hertz). The corporation is a citizen of Delaware and Georgia, so it is not diverse from a Georgia plaintiff.
A plaintiff sues in state court on a state-law contract claim. The defendant's answer asserts a federal defense under a federal statute. May the defendant remove the case to federal court?
Yes, because a federal question is raised
Yes, if all defendants consent
No, because a federal defense does not create federal question jurisdiction under the well-pleaded complaint rule
Yes, but only within 30 days of the answer
Federal question jurisdiction depends on the plaintiff's well-pleaded complaint. A federal defense or counterclaim does not give the case an original federal basis, so there is nothing to remove unless diversity exists.
A defendant has minimal contact with State X: it sold a product online to a single customer in State X, who sued for harm from the product. Another plaintiff from State X sues the defendant for an unrelated contract made in State Y. For the second claim, what kind of personal jurisdiction would State X need?
Specific jurisdiction, which exists because of the earlier sale
General jurisdiction, which the defendant lacks because it is not at home in State X
No jurisdiction is needed, because the plaintiff lives in State X
Jurisdiction by consent, which is automatic
Specific jurisdiction requires that the claim arise out of or relate to the defendant's forum contacts. The unrelated claim does not, so State X needs general jurisdiction, which exists only where the defendant is at home (for a corporation, its state of incorporation and principal place of business).
Which is true about a defense of improper venue under Rule 12?
It is waived if not raised in the defendant's first Rule 12 motion or responsive pleading
It can be raised at any time before trial
It can be raised for the first time on appeal
It is never waived
Defenses of lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient process and insufficient service of process are waived if not included in the first Rule 12 motion or answer (Rule 12(h)(1)). Lack of subject-matter jurisdiction is never waived.
A plaintiff files a complaint on January 1 and serves the defendant on January 10. When must the defendant respond to the complaint, absent waiver of service?
By January 21
By February 9
By March 11
By January 31 (21 days after service)
A defendant must serve an answer or file a Rule 12 motion within 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint (Rule 12(a)(1)(A)(i)). January 10 plus 21 days is January 31. A defendant who waives service has 60 days from the date the request was sent.
In a federal diversity case, a valid Federal Rule of Civil Procedure directly conflicts with a state procedural rule on the same point. Which applies?
The state rule, because Erie requires state law in diversity cases
The rule that is more favorable to the plaintiff
The Federal Rule, under Hanna v. Plumer
The rule of whichever state has more contacts
When a valid Federal Rule of Civil Procedure directly covers the point, it controls, as long as it is within the Rules Enabling Act (Hanna v. Plumer). The twin aims test of Erie applies only if no Federal Rule covers the point.
In an action by P against D arising from a car accident, D wishes to assert a claim against P for D's own injuries from the same accident. Is this counterclaim compulsory?
No, because counterclaims are always permissive
Yes, because it arises from the same transaction or occurrence
No, because it seeks damages for a different party
Yes, but only if it exceeds 75,000 dollars
Rule 13(a) requires a defendant to assert any claim against the plaintiff arising out of the same transaction or occurrence. If D fails to assert it, it is barred in later litigation. Supplemental jurisdiction applies, so no independent basis is needed.
P sues D for breach of contract. D believes that X is liable to D for any amount D owes P. Which procedure lets D bring X into the case?
Impleader under Rule 14
Interpleader under Rule 22
Intervention under Rule 24
Permissive joinder under Rule 20 by P
Impleader allows a defendant to bring in a nonparty who is or may be liable to the defendant for all or part of the plaintiff's claim (indemnification, contribution). Interpleader involves a stakeholder facing competing claims. Intervention is initiated by a nonparty.
In discovery, P seeks documents that D's lawyer prepared after the accident, in anticipation of a lawsuit, summarizing interviews with witnesses. What protection applies?
No protection, because the documents are not communications with the client
Absolute protection, because they were prepared by a lawyer
No protection, because they are relevant to the case
Work product protection, which P can overcome only by showing substantial need and inability to obtain the equivalent
Documents prepared in anticipation of litigation by or for a party or its representative are protected as work product, but the opponent can obtain them with a showing of substantial need and undue hardship. Mental impressions of counsel are nearly absolutely protected.
At the close of the plaintiff's case, the defendant moves for judgment as a matter of law, which is denied. The jury returns a verdict for the plaintiff. Which statement is correct about the defendant's post-trial options?
The defendant may make the motion for the first time after the verdict
The defendant cannot challenge the verdict on the basis of the evidence
The defendant may renew the motion within 28 days after judgment, because the motion was made before submission to the jury
The defendant must file an appeal first
A Rule 50(b) renewed motion for JMOL is allowed only if the movant made a Rule 50(a) motion before the case went to the jury, and must be filed within 28 days after the entry of judgment. A Rule 59 motion for a new trial is a separate option.
In P's first suit against D for negligence, a judgment is entered for D after trial. P then sues D again for the same accident, but alleges a different theory (strict liability). What is the likely result?
Not barred, because the legal theory is different
Barred by claim preclusion, because the claim arises from the same transaction and could have been brought
Not barred, because the first suit was only for negligence
Barred only if the first court addressed strict liability
Claim preclusion bars claims arising from the same transaction or occurrence that were or could have been raised in the first action between the same parties. Changing the legal theory does not create a new claim.
In an earlier suit by P against D, a jury found that D negligently caused a train derailment. X, another injured passenger who was not a party to the first suit, now sues D and asks the court to bar D from relitigating whether D was negligent. What is X seeking?
Nonmutual offensive issue preclusion
Claim preclusion
Mutual defensive issue preclusion
Res judicata by privity
X was not a party to the earlier suit and seeks to use the earlier finding against D to establish liability: nonmutual offensive collateral estoppel. The court has discretion to allow it (Parklane Hosiery), considering fairness, such as whether D had a full and fair chance to litigate and whether X could have joined the earlier suit.
Which of the following is a final judgment that can be appealed as of right?
A denial of a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction
A discovery order requiring a party to produce documents
An order denying a motion to compel arbitration
A judgment for the defendant after a jury trial on all claims
Under 28 U.S.C. sec. 1291, appeals as of right lie from final decisions ending the litigation on the merits. Orders denying motions to dismiss and discovery orders are interlocutory and generally cannot be appealed immediately, except through narrow exceptions.
Which of the following is NOT a requirement for class certification under Rule 23(a)?
Numerosity
Commonality
Superiority of the class action over other methods
Adequacy of representation
Rule 23(a) requires numerosity, commonality, typicality, and adequacy. Superiority is a requirement only for Rule 23(b)(3) classes, together with predominance.