Quiz · Hard
Harder applied questions on range of fire, reconstruction, kinetic energy, examiner conclusions and limits of firearms evidence.
A victim's clothing shows a ring of dense stippling around a 9 mm hole, but no soot. The most likely range is:
Intermediate
Distant
Cannot say
Contact
Stippling without soot suggests the muzzle was far enough that soot did not reach, but close enough for unburned powder grains.
A test-fire of the suspect gun at 12 inches produces powder tattooing 3 inches wide, and at 24 inches 5 inches. The victim's pattern is 4 inches wide. A reasonable estimate is:
Over 5 feet
Between 12 and 24 inches
Less than 12 inches
Contact range
Pattern size increases with distance, so 4 inches falls between the two known distances. The same gun and ammunition must be used.
A window has two bullet holes with radial fractures. One radial crack from hole B stops at a crack from hole A. Which shot came first?
Cannot be determined
A
B
Both at the same time
A fracture stops when it meets an existing fracture, so the cracks that end against another are later.
A bullet has an elongated entrance hole with the abrasion collar wider on the left. Which interpretation fits?
It struck bone
It came at an angle, from the left side
It was a ricochet only
It was a contact shot
The abrasion is widest on the side from which the bullet arrived at an oblique angle.
A 9 mm handgun bullet (8 g at 350 m/s) and a rifle bullet (4 g at 950 m/s) are compared. Which has the greater kinetic energy and by about how much?
The rifle bullet, about 1.2 times
The handgun bullet, about 2 times
They are equal
The rifle bullet, about 3.7 times
Handgun: J. Rifle: J. Ratio is about 3.7.
Two cartridge cases from different crime scenes have matching firing pin impressions, but different breech face marks. What should the examiner conclude?
Not enough agreement for identification; it is likely inconclusive or an elimination depending on the differences
They are definitely from the same gun
Identification
The gun was modified between shots
Agreement in some marks with significant disagreement in others generally prevents an identification, and the examiner must explain the differences.
An examiner states a bullet came from the suspect's gun 'to the exclusion of all other firearms in the world'. Which criticism applies?
Ballistics has a known zero error rate
The claim is an accepted standard
The 2009 NAS and 2016 PCAST reports said such absolute claims are not supported by validation data
It is correct only for bullets
These reports criticized the subjectivity and the lack of error rate studies.
Which statement about subclass characteristics is correct?
They are caused by use
They are shared by a small group of firearms made with the same tool, and can cause false identifications
They are unique to one gun
They are class characteristics
Subclass features result from manufacturing tools and are not individual.
A suspect has GSR particles of Pb, Ba and Sb on his hands 10 hours after the shooting; he claims to have been arrested and handled by police. What is the best interpretation?
Meaningless because Pb, Ba and Sb are common
Proof he fired a gun
The particles are consistent with firing, handling or proximity; transfer cannot be excluded and persistence after 10 hours is unlikely
Proof he was not the shooter
GSR is lost quickly and can transfer by contact. Pb-Ba-Sb are characteristic but not proof of who fired.
A bullet's path through a wall lined up with a laser from the entrance hole to the exit hole is 20 degrees downward. What is the most defensible conclusion?
The shooter's position was higher than the target along that line, subject to deflection and movement of the victim
The shooter was exactly 20 degrees from the vertical
The shooter was at the ground
The bullet was a ricochet
Trajectory rods give a line, but deflection and posture of the victim limit precision.
A round hole in the skull is wider on the outer surface than on the inner surface. What does this indicate?
It is an exit wound
It was made by a ricochet
It is a contact wound only
It is an entrance wound
Skull entrance wounds bevel inward (wider on the inner surface). A hole that widens toward the outside was made by a bullet leaving the skull.
A NIBIN hit links two shootings. What must happen before this is used as evidence of a link?
DNA must be recovered
An examiner must confirm the comparison on the microscope
Nothing, the correlation is enough
A third lab must repeat NIBIN
NIBIN only ranks candidates, and a trained examiner has to confirm.
A hollow-point bullet and an FMJ bullet of equal mass and speed hit gelatin. Which result is expected?
The FMJ expands more
The hollow point expands and transfers more energy, with less penetration
No difference
The hollow-point penetrates deeper
Expansion increases the frontal area, transferring more energy within a shorter distance.
In a black-box study of firearm examiners, what is measured?
DNA mixture
How the gun works
The type of ammunition
The rate at which examiners reach correct or incorrect conclusions without regard to their reasoning
Black-box studies measure outputs (error rates) of the examiners' whole process.