Quiz · Medium
Fourteen MPRE-style questions on Model Rules 1.5, 1.6, 1.7 to 1.9, 1.15, 3.3, 3.8, 4.2, 5.3, 7.1, 7.3, 8.3 and 8.4 and the Code of Judicial Conduct.
A client tells his lawyer that he plans to forge a signature on a loan application that will cause a bank to lose 200,000 dollars, and that he will use documents the lawyer prepared. Under the Model Rules, what may the lawyer do?
Nothing, because the information is confidential and no exception applies
Reveal the information to the extent reasonably necessary to prevent the fraud, because the client is using the lawyer's services
Reveal the information only after the loss has occurred
Reveal the information only if the bank requests it
Rule 1.6(b)(2) permits (but does not require) disclosure to prevent a client crime or fraud that is reasonably certain to cause substantial financial injury and in which the client has used or is using the lawyer's services. The lawyer must also consider Rule 1.2(d) and withdrawal.
A lawyer sends a letter by mail to a person who has just been injured in a train accident, offering representation. The letter is truthful and is labeled as an advertisement. Is this permitted?
No, because all solicitation of accident victims is prohibited
No, because the lawyer must wait 30 days
Yes, because a written, non-coercive solicitation is not prohibited by the Model Rules
Only if the victim has already contacted the lawyer
Rule 7.3 bans live person-to-person solicitation (in-person, live telephone, real-time electronic) for pecuniary gain, but permits written, recorded, or electronic communications that are not real-time, as long as they are not false or misleading and not coercive (Rule 7.1, 7.3(c)).
A lawyer represents a client in a business transaction. The lawyer also wishes to invest in the client's business on terms that are fair and reasonable. What must the lawyer do under Rule 1.8(a)?
Disclose the terms in writing in a way the client can understand, advise the client in writing to seek independent counsel, and obtain the client's informed written consent
Nothing, because the terms are fair
Obtain the client's oral consent only
Obtain consent from the court
Rule 1.8(a) requires that the transaction and terms be fair and reasonable and fully disclosed in writing; that the client be advised in writing of the desirability of seeking independent legal counsel and given a reasonable chance to do so; and that the client give informed consent, in writing, to the essential terms and the lawyer's role.
A lawyer in a personal injury case agrees with the client on a one-third contingent fee, by an oral agreement. After winning the case, the lawyer takes one-third of the recovery. Has the lawyer violated the Model Rules?
No, because a one-third fee is reasonable
No, because oral fee agreements are always valid
Yes, because contingent fees are prohibited in personal injury cases
Yes, because a contingent fee agreement must be in writing and signed by the client
Rule 1.5(c) requires a contingent fee agreement to be in a writing signed by the client, stating how the fee is determined, the percentages, and the expenses to be deducted. Contingent fees are prohibited only in criminal cases and in domestic relations cases for divorce or the amount of alimony or support.
A lawyer represents A in a lawsuit against B. B's lawyer, without telling the lawyer, sends B to talk directly with A about settling. A calls his lawyer. May the lawyer talk to B directly about the matter, if B wants to speak with him?
Yes, because B initiated the contact
Yes, because A authorized it
No, unless B's lawyer consents, because B is represented in the matter
Yes, if the lawyer informs B that he represents A
Rule 4.2 prohibits a lawyer from communicating about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows is represented by another lawyer in the matter, unless that lawyer consents or the communication is authorized by law or court order. The represented person's consent or initiation is not enough.
In a civil case, a lawyer's witness testifies falsely on a material fact. The lawyer knows it is false. The lawyer's remonstration with the witness fails. What must the lawyer do?
Nothing, because the information is confidential
Take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure to the tribunal if necessary
Withdraw immediately without further action
Wait until the end of the trial and then report the matter to the bar
Rule 3.3(a)(3) and (b): if a lawyer comes to know that evidence offered is false and material, the lawyer must take reasonable remedial measures, including, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal. This duty overrides the duty of confidentiality and lasts until the conclusion of the proceeding.
A lawyer represents both a husband and a wife in a joint estate plan, and has told them that information from either will be shared with the other. The wife privately tells the lawyer she plans to change her will to disinherit the husband. What is the lawyer's best course?
Ask the wife to tell the husband and, if she refuses, withdraw, because the lawyer cannot keep the secret from a co-client
Keep the secret and continue representing both
Tell the husband immediately without giving the wife a chance to disclose
Continue to represent the wife only and keep the husband's file
In a joint representation, the clients' information is shared, and the lawyer owes a duty of communication to both (Rule 1.4) and is bound by the Rule 1.7 conflict analysis. The lawyer should urge the wife to disclose the plan, and if she will not, withdraw. Keeping the secret from the husband would breach duties to him.
A lawyer receives a settlement check for a client. The lawyer's fee is one-third and the lawyer has earned it. The client disputes the amount of the fee. What must the lawyer do with the disputed portion?
Deposit the whole check into the lawyer's operating account
Distribute the entire check to the lawyer, since the fee is earned
Give the whole amount to the client
Keep the disputed amount in the client trust account until the dispute is resolved, and promptly distribute the undisputed portion
Rule 1.15(e): when the lawyer and client dispute their interests in funds, the disputed portion must be kept separate until the dispute is resolved, and the undisputed portion must be promptly distributed. Commingling is prohibited.
A prosecutor learns, after a conviction becomes final, of new, credible evidence that creates a reasonable likelihood that the defendant is innocent. What must the prosecutor do under Rule 3.8?
Nothing, because the conviction is final
Promptly disclose the evidence to the appropriate court or authority and, if the conviction was obtained in the prosecutor's jurisdiction, undertake further investigation
Wait until the defendant files a petition
Disclose only if the defendant has no other remedy
Rule 3.8(g) and (h) require a prosecutor who knows of new, credible and material evidence creating a reasonable likelihood of innocence to disclose it, and to investigate or seek to remedy the conviction if clear and convincing evidence of innocence is known.
Before a trial begins, a judge privately tells friends that he thinks the defendant is "a liar and a thief." Which statement is correct?
The judge must disqualify himself for personal bias or prejudice concerning a party, and the parties cannot waive this ground
The judge may continue, because he has not yet heard the evidence
The judge may continue if the defendant waives the issue
The judge may continue if he discloses the remark to the parties
Under Model Code of Judicial Conduct Rule 2.11, a judge must disqualify himself in any proceeding in which his impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including personal bias or prejudice concerning a party. Other grounds may be waived after disclosure, but bias or prejudice cannot.
A lawyer learns that a partner has been taking money from the firm's client trust account. The partner promises to repay the funds before any client notices. Must the lawyer report the partner's conduct?
No, because the funds will be repaid
No, because only the clients can report
No, because the partner is a senior lawyer
Yes, because it raises a substantial question about the partner's honesty, and repayment does not excuse the duty to report
Rule 8.3(a) requires a lawyer who knows another lawyer has committed a violation raising a substantial question about honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness to inform the appropriate professional authority, unless the information is protected by Rule 1.6. A promise to repay does not eliminate the duty.
A lawyer's nonlawyer assistant, who is supervised by the lawyer, shares confidential client information with a friend. The lawyer did not know, but had no procedures for protecting client information. May the lawyer be disciplined?
No, because the lawyer did not know
No, because the assistant is not a lawyer
Yes, because the lawyer failed to make reasonable efforts to ensure the assistant's conduct complies with the Rules
No, because the information was not privileged
Rule 5.3 requires lawyers with supervisory authority to make reasonable efforts to ensure that a nonlawyer's conduct is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations. Failure to maintain reasonable safeguards can result in discipline, even without knowledge.
After a case ends, a lawyer who had represented a client in a custody dispute is asked by the other parent to represent her in a new dispute against the former client over the same child. May the lawyer take the case?
Yes, because the earlier case has ended
No, unless the former client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing, because the matter is substantially related and adverse
Yes, because the lawyer will not use confidential information
Yes, if the lawyer gets a court order
Rule 1.9(a) bars representation in the same or a substantially related matter in which the new client's interests are materially adverse to the former client's, unless the former client gives informed consent confirmed in writing. A new dispute about the same child is substantially related.
A lawyer wants to advertise that she has "never lost a jury trial." She has tried two jury cases, both of which she won. Is the advertisement permitted?
No, because it is misleading: it creates an unjustified expectation about results
Yes, because the statement is literally true
Yes, if she adds the number of cases tried
No, because the Model Rules prohibit any statements about results
Rule 7.1 prohibits false or misleading communications, including those that omit facts necessary to make the statement not materially misleading. A statement that implies a record of success based on a tiny sample is likely to mislead a reasonable person.
A lawyer is charged with a misdemeanor for disorderly conduct after a bar fight. The offense has nothing to do with honesty or the practice of law. May the lawyer be disciplined?
Yes, because any criminal act is misconduct
Yes, because the lawyer was convicted
No, only if the conviction is expunged
Probably not, because the conduct does not reflect adversely on honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer
Rule 8.4(b) covers criminal acts that reflect adversely on the lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects. Offenses of a purely personal nature, unrelated to fitness, ordinarily do not warrant discipline.