Quiz · Hard
Bar-style fact patterns on anticommandeering, spending coercion, removal and immunity, recent overrulings (Dobbs, SFFA, Loper Bright, Bruen) and the correct standard of review.
A federal statute prohibits a state's legislature from authorizing sports betting. A state sues. What is the best argument that the statute is invalid?
It violates the Eleventh Amendment
It exceeds the commerce power because gambling is non-economic
It is a bill of attainder against states
It commandeers the state legislature by dictating what laws the state may pass
Murphy v. NCAA (2018) held the anti-authorization provision was commandeering, even though phrased as a prohibition. Gambling is economic activity, so the commerce argument fails.
Congress threatens to withdraw all of a state's existing Medicaid funding unless the state adopts a new eligibility expansion. Under NFIB v. Sebelius, the condition is
constitutional, because Congress has plenary spending power
unconstitutional, because the threat was a gun to the head, not a mere inducement
constitutional, because states can always decline all federal funds
unconstitutional, because spending conditions must relate to commerce
Chief Justice Roberts found the expansion coercive because it threatened the loss of a large share of existing funding. The ability to decline all funds does not defeat a coercion claim.
The Affordable Care Act's individual mandate was upheld in NFIB v. Sebelius under which power?
The Commerce Clause
The Necessary and Proper Clause
The taxing power
The Spending Clause
The majority held the mandate could not be sustained under the Commerce Clause (compelling inactivity) but the penalty functioned as a tax within Congress's taxing power.
A state bans double-trailer trucks from its highways, citing safety. The ban is neutral on its face, the evidence shows no real safety benefit, and it forces much interstate traffic to detour around the state. The best analysis is that the law is
invalid under Pike balancing, because the burden on interstate commerce is clearly excessive relative to the local benefit
valid, because highway safety is a traditional state interest
invalid, because any burden on interstate commerce is forbidden
valid, because the Tenth Amendment reserves highway regulation to the states
Facially neutral laws are weighed under Pike. Safety is a legitimate interest, but courts do not accept it blindly when the real benefit is slight and the burden heavy (Kassel v. Consolidated Freightways).
Congress creates an agency headed by a single director removable by the President only for inefficiency, neglect, or malfeasance, with substantial executive power. After Seila Law, this structure is
unconstitutional, because the single head exercises executive power without being accountable to the President
constitutional under Humphrey's Executor
constitutional because Congress may structure agencies freely
unconstitutional because agency heads may never be removed for cause
Seila Law (2020) confined Humphrey's Executor to multi-member bodies of experts without substantial executive power, and the Morrison exception to inferior officers with limited duties.
A congressional statute allows either house, by resolution, to overturn a decision of the Attorney General. This is
constitutional, because Congress oversees the executive
constitutional if two-thirds of one house agree
unconstitutional, because it is lawmaking without bicameralism and presentment
unconstitutional only if it affects individual rights
INS v. Chadha (1983): any action that has the effect of altering legal rights and duties must follow Article I, §7.
A former President is prosecuted for conversations with the Attorney General about the Justice Department's investigations. Under Trump v. United States (2024), the best analysis is that the conduct
receives only presumptive immunity, which the prosecution can easily rebut
is within the President's core constitutional powers and receives absolute immunity
receives no immunity because the President is not above the law
receives immunity only if it was lawful
The Court held that the President's exclusive core powers, such as conferring with the Justice Department on investigations, get absolute immunity. Other official acts get presumptive immunity, and unofficial acts get none.
A state university considers an applicant's race as one factor among many to promote diversity. After Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard (2023), the program is
constitutional under Grutter v. Bollinger
constitutional if it avoids quotas
reviewed under intermediate scrutiny, which it passes
unconstitutional, because it lacks measurable objectives, uses race in a way that functions as a negative, and has no end point
The Court applied strict scrutiny and held the asserted diversity interests were not sufficiently measurable and the programs lacked a logical endpoint. Grutter was effectively overruled.
A state statute denies a public benefit to everyone over 70. A plaintiff challenges it under equal protection. The result is most likely that the law
is subject to strict scrutiny because the elderly are a discrete and insular minority
is subject to intermediate scrutiny
survives rational basis review, because age is not a suspect classification
is invalid because age discrimination is illegal
Massachusetts Board of Retirement v. Murgia (1976): age is not suspect, so rational basis applies. Federal statutes may separately prohibit age discrimination.
A federal law restricts a fundamental right but is defended as rationally related to a legitimate end. Which approach is correct under substantive due process?
Strict scrutiny applies if the right is fundamental, requiring a compelling interest and narrow tailoring
Rational basis applies to all substantive due process claims
Intermediate scrutiny applies to rights not in the text
Courts must defer to the legislature on rights not in the text
Substantive due process applies strict scrutiny to infringements of fundamental rights. Whether a right is fundamental depends on whether it is deeply rooted in history and tradition (Glucksberg).
After Dobbs, a state ban on abortion is reviewed under
strict scrutiny, because abortion is a fundamental right
the undue burden test from Casey
intermediate scrutiny
rational basis, because there is no constitutional right to abortion
Dobbs (2022) overruled Roe and Casey, held that abortion is not deeply rooted in history and tradition, and said laws regulating abortion are presumed valid and survive if rationally related to legitimate interests.
A government fires an employee without a hearing. Which first question must a court ask to decide the procedural due process claim?
Whether the firing was motivated by animus
Whether the employee has a protected liberty or property interest
Whether the government used the least restrictive means
Whether the employee had a fundamental right to the job
Procedural due process asks first whether there is a deprivation of a protected interest (a property interest such as a legitimate entitlement to continued employment). Only then do the Mathews factors determine what process is due.
A town bans all temporary directional signs but allows signs for government events and ideological signs with larger dimensions. The ordinance is subject to
intermediate scrutiny, because it is a time, place, and manner rule
strict scrutiny, because the rules depend on the signs' message (Reed)
rational basis, because signs are commercial
no scrutiny, because the town owns the streets
Under Reed, a law that applies to speech based on its topic or purpose is content-based on its face and requires strict scrutiny, regardless of the town's neutral motive.
A city regulation prevents any development on a landowner's coastal lot, depriving it of all economic value. The city argues the regulation advances the public interest. Under Lucas, the city must
compensate only if the regulation lacks a rational basis
compensate only if a physical occupation occurs
avoid compensation if the benefit to the public is great
compensate the owner unless the restriction inheres in background principles of nuisance or property law
Lucas created a categorical rule for total deprivation of economic value. The public benefit of the regulation does not matter if the exception does not apply.
A state enacts a law that retroactively increases the punishment for a crime committed before the law's effective date. Which provision does the law most directly violate?
The Ex Post Facto Clause
The Bill of Attainder Clause
The Contracts Clause
The Takings Clause
Retroactive increases in criminal punishment violate Article I, §10 (states) and §9 (Congress). Bills of attainder require legislative punishment of named individuals or groups without trial.
Congress conditions a grant for school lunch programs on the state adopting a nondiscrimination policy for that program. The condition is
invalid, because it commandeers the state legislature
invalid, because Congress cannot regulate discrimination by states
valid under the Spending Clause, because it is related to the federal interest in the program
invalid, because Congress may only set conditions on private entities
Conditions related to the federal purpose are permitted under Dole as long as they are not coercive. The state may decline the money, which is why this is not commandeering.
Which of the following correctly describes the test the Supreme Court used in Bruen to evaluate a Second Amendment challenge?
Courts balance the interest in public safety against the burden on gun owners
Courts apply intermediate scrutiny
Courts ask whether the law is a reasonable regulation
The government must show the regulation is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation
Bruen rejected the two-step framework with means-end scrutiny that many lower courts had used and required reliance on text and historical analogues.
A federal agency adopts an interpretation of an ambiguous statute. After Loper Bright (2024), a court reviewing the interpretation should
defer to any reasonable agency interpretation
exercise independent judgment about the best reading, giving weight to the agency's view only to the extent it is persuasive
defer only if Congress expressly delegates authority in the statute
defer if the agency's reading was adopted by notice-and-comment rulemaking
Loper Bright overruled Chevron. Courts may still respect an agency's expertise, but cannot defer merely because a statute is ambiguous. Express delegations of discretionary authority remain valid.
A state legislature draws congressional districts to favor one party, and voters sue in federal court claiming the partisan gerrymander violates the Constitution. Under Rucho v. Common Cause, the suit is
justiciable, because malapportionment cases are justiciable
justiciable only if the plaintiffs are a racial minority
a nonjusticiable political question
justiciable if the gerrymander is extreme
Rucho (2019) held that there are no judicially manageable standards for partisan gerrymandering. Racial gerrymandering and malapportionment claims remain justiciable.
Which of the following is the best example of state action by a private party?
A private company that runs a town and performs a traditional governmental function exercising police powers
A private hospital that receives Medicare funding
A private university that is regulated by the state
A private club that holds a state liquor license
Public function doctrine reaches private actors performing functions traditionally and exclusively governmental (Marsh v. Alabama, company town). Funding, regulation, and licenses alone are not enough.