Quiz · Medium
Twenty-one fact-pattern questions on the core elements of intentional torts, defamation, negligence, defenses and basic strict liability.
Mia borrows Leo's bicycle for a day, as agreed, but keeps it for six months and sells it. Which tort has Mia most likely committed?
Trespass to chattels
Conversion
Battery
Negligence
Selling the bike, or keeping it for a very long time, is a serious interference with the owner's right of control, so Mia must pay its full value: conversion. Trespass to chattels is for lesser interference, where damages are limited to the loss in value or use.
Dan, intending only to frighten Pam, swings a baseball bat close to her head and misses. Pam sees it and is terrified. Which tort has Dan committed?
Battery
Assault
Intentional infliction of emotional distress only
False imprisonment
Assault requires an intentional act causing reasonable apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact. No contact occurred, so there is no battery. IIED is possible but not the best answer, because assault fits the facts exactly. There is no confinement, so no false imprisonment.
Alex throws a punch at Ben, misses, and hits Carl, a bystander. Alex did not intend to hit Carl. Is Alex liable to Carl for battery?
Yes, because Alex's intent to commit battery against Ben transfers to Carl
No, because Alex did not intend to hit Carl
No, because Alex's punch missed its intended target
Only if Carl was foreseeable
Under the transferred intent doctrine, intent to commit assault, battery, false imprisonment, trespass to land, or trespass to chattels against one person transfers to the actual victim. Foreseeability is a negligence concept and does not matter for intentional torts.
A security guard locks a customer in a back room for ten minutes because he mistakenly believes she shoplifted. The customer did not steal. The guard had reasonable grounds for suspicion and acted reasonably. Is the store liable for false imprisonment?
Yes, because the customer did not steal
Yes, because a mistake of fact is no defense to false imprisonment
No, because the customer was not actually harmed
No, because the shopkeeper's privilege applies
The shopkeeper's privilege protects a merchant who detains a person on reasonable grounds to suspect theft, for a reasonable time and in a reasonable manner, even if the suspicion turns out to be wrong. A mistake of fact is usually no defense to false imprisonment, but this privilege is the exception.
Which of the following is required for intentional infliction of emotional distress, but NOT for battery?
Intent or recklessness
Causation
Extreme and outrageous conduct
Physical contact
IIED requires conduct that is extreme and outrageous, beyond all bounds of decency. Both torts require intent (recklessness also suffices for IIED) and causation. Physical contact is an element of battery, not IIED.
A neighbor hits a golf ball that lands in Rosa's yard. A moment later the neighbor walks into the yard to retrieve the ball, believing it is public land. Is the neighbor liable for trespass to land?
Yes, because the neighbor intended to enter the land and a mistake about ownership is no defense
No, because the neighbor lacked intent to trespass
No, because there was no damage
Yes, but only if Rosa objected
The intent required for trespass to land is only to enter the land (or to cause an object to enter). A good-faith mistake about ownership is no defense, and damages need not be proved: nominal damages are available.
Which statement about defamation is correct?
Slander always requires proof of special damages
A statement of opinion can never be defamatory
Publication requires the statement to be written
Truth is a defense, and for a matter of public concern the plaintiff must prove falsity
Truth is generally a defense, and for matters of public concern the plaintiff bears the burden of proving falsity. Slander per se categories do not require special damages. Opinions implying false facts can be defamatory. Publication means communication to a third person, orally or in writing.
A newspaper, without malice but negligently, publishes a false statement that a local shop owner (a private person) was arrested for fraud. This matter is of public concern. What can the shop owner recover?
Presumed and punitive damages
Nothing, because the paper acted without malice
Actual damages, but not presumed or punitive damages unless actual malice is shown
Only nominal damages
Under Gertz, a private plaintiff on a matter of public concern must show at least negligence, and may recover actual damages. Presumed and punitive damages require proof of actual malice.
Which of the following is NOT one of the four privacy torts?
Intrusion upon seclusion
Negligent infliction of privacy harm
Appropriation of name or likeness
Public disclosure of private facts
The four privacy torts are appropriation, intrusion upon seclusion, public disclosure of private facts, and false light. There is no tort of negligent infliction of privacy harm.
Which of these is a complete defense to a battery claim when the defendant acts within its scope?
Consent
Contributory negligence
Comparative fault of the plaintiff
Mistake of fact in all cases
Consent, actual or implied, is a complete defense to an intentional tort as long as the defendant stays within its scope. Contributory negligence is not a defense to intentional torts. A mistake of fact only matters for self-defense and similar privileges.
Sam, in his front yard, is attacked by Tom, who punches him. Sam shoves Tom away with reasonable force. Is Sam liable for battery?
Yes, because Sam made contact
Yes, because Sam had a duty to retreat
No, but only if Tom was armed
No, because Sam used reasonable force in self-defense
Self-defense permits reasonable, proportional force against an imminent threat. Sam has no duty to retreat before using non-deadly force. Tom does not need a weapon for a threat of harmful contact to justify reasonable non-deadly force.
Which of the following is TRUE of private necessity?
The actor owes nothing for any damage
The property owner may use force to eject the actor
The actor is privileged to use another's property but must pay for actual damage
The privilege applies only to government officials
Under Vincent v. Lake Erie, private necessity lets the actor use another's property to prevent greater harm, but the actor must compensate for actual damage. The owner cannot lawfully resist the privileged use. Public necessity is the complete privilege.
What is the standard of care for a 10-year-old child riding a bicycle?
A reasonably prudent adult
A reasonable child of similar age, intelligence and experience
No duty because of age
Gross negligence only
Children are held to the standard of a reasonable child of like age, intelligence, and experience. The adult standard applies only to adult activities such as driving a car or operating a motorboat.
A statute requires that all construction sites install fences to keep out children. A contractor fails to do so, and an adult trespasser at night falls into a pit. Will negligence per se likely apply?
No, because the adult was not in the class of persons the statute was meant to protect
Yes, because any statutory violation is negligence per se
Yes, because the contractor is strictly liable
No, because trespassers are never owed a duty
Negligence per se requires that the plaintiff belong to the protected class and that the harm be of the type the statute was meant to prevent. The fence was meant to protect children, so an adult plaintiff cannot rely on it.
A pedestrian is hit by a barrel that falls from a warehouse window. She cannot show who dropped it. Which doctrine may let her case reach the jury?
Respondeat superior
Strict liability
Last clear chance
Res ipsa loquitur
Res ipsa loquitur allows an inference of negligence when the accident ordinarily does not happen without negligence, the instrumentality was in the defendant's exclusive control, and the plaintiff did not contribute (Byrne v. Boadle).
Which rule fully bars a plaintiff's recovery when the plaintiff is 1 percent at fault?
Pure comparative fault
Modified comparative fault (50 percent bar)
Contributory negligence
Assumption of risk under comparative fault
In the few remaining contributory negligence jurisdictions, any fault by the plaintiff that contributes to the harm bars recovery. Comparative fault systems reduce the damages by the plaintiff's share.
A rescuer is injured while reasonably attempting to save a person endangered by the defendant's negligence. Is the defendant liable to the rescuer?
No, because the rescuer assumed the risk
Yes, because rescue is foreseeable
No, because the defendant owed no duty to the rescuer
Only if the rescuer was a professional
Under the rescue doctrine, a defendant whose negligence endangers someone is liable to a rescuer who is injured in a reasonable rescue attempt. Professional rescuers are usually limited by the firefighter's rule.
A dog owner knows that her dog has bitten before. The dog bites a visitor. Under the traditional rule, what is the basis of liability?
Strict liability, because the owner knew of the animal's dangerous propensity
Negligence only
No liability for the first-known bite
Liability only if the visitor is an invitee
Owners of domestic animals are strictly liable for harm resulting from the animal's known dangerous propensities. Wild animals are subject to strict liability regardless of the knowledge of the owner.
Which of the following is a design defect claim?
A single bottle in a batch contains broken glass
A medicine is sold without any warnings about known risks
A product is sold under a misleading brand name
A car's fuel tank could have been placed in a safer location at small cost, and the placement caused a fire after a crash
A design defect exists when the foreseeable risks of harm could have been reduced or avoided by a reasonable alternative design. A single bottle with glass is a manufacturing defect, and missing warnings are a failure-to-warn claim.
A private nuisance claim generally requires which of the following?
A physical invasion of the land
Proof that the defendant intended to harm the plaintiff
A substantial and unreasonable interference with the use and enjoyment of land
A showing of harm to the general public
Private nuisance concerns substantial, unreasonable interference with another's use and enjoyment of land, such as noise, odor or smoke. A physical invasion is trespass, and harm to the public is the basis of public nuisance.
What does the "zone of danger" rule govern?
Duty to rescue
Direct recovery for negligent infliction of emotional distress
Strict liability for animals
Assumption of risk
The zone of danger rule allows recovery for NIED to a plaintiff who was placed at risk of physical harm by the defendant's negligence and who suffers emotional distress with physical symptoms.